Search results

Thanks Bovine, I really appreciate it! :D I'm a CS grad student so I'm pretty used to writing stuff like this up in LaTeX :P I definitely see your concern about the width of the Runestone lands and room for agriculture. From eyeballing the dynmap, I think it will be just enough space to have a...

AKA another thing to keep me occupied for the next 10 years... This megabuild consists of Wickenden (finished; just minor post-approval updates pending), Ruthermont, Redfort, Runestone, and Gulltown. The city of Gulltown itself will be a separate server build applied for at a later date...

Hey Frenci, Really nice work on this farmstead, I think you did a great job of representing the various aspects of the farm and adding immersive details. I don't have much feedback to give except for a few very picky things: - The gradients are still a little messy in some spots. For instance...

Here's some various salt marsh pics from my travels, as promised! https://www.dropbox.com/sh/55r1fjsxh79bkcq/AACJnm8ZcTKBQhKUICPsGrv7a?dl=0

Hi Venboven, could you let us know which launcher you’re using? Also, have you migrated your Mojang account to a Microsoft account?

I think that seems reasonable. Only thing I'd change is adding a little more of a buffer along the part where the river exits the valley. Also, I wouldn't mind seeing the style of chalet houses in the original app used in more rural/high-altitude parts of the project, as a way to glue over the...

Hey shoe, Great work on this challenge! It's a pretty difficult style and you nailed it. The only feedback I have is a couple pretty nitpicky things: - It's a bit hard to tell from the angle of the photo, but I probably wouldn't use the peaked thatch roof design (with the rounded-off top) for...

I think I can see a way forward with this project without being majorly affected by the height limit increase, since like you mentioned it happens to be in a fairly isolated and wide valley. The main thing to consider is that the entire valley might be raised upwards in the future in order to...

No worries, welcome back! Feel free to pick up right where you left off.

Hey Alex, These tests look absolutely gorgeous; I'm in love! The only concern that I have is that the future of the "inner Vale" as a whole (i.e., the region stretching from the Vale of Arryn to Newkeep) is sort of in a bind right now considering the news of the 1.18 height limit increase and...

Hey Frenci, As before, excellent work on this house, everything looks really good! I'd say that you're just about up to server standards already. I do have a little bit of feedback to give though: - Avoid using the "path" dirt/gravel blocks in small yards like this, since it just adds...

Hey Frenci, Apologies for the delay in response, in the future feel free to ping me if it's been more than a couple days with no reply. Overall excellent work with your initial submission, you really went beyond expectations! The interiors in particular look fantastic. I didn't notice any...

Hey NMF, I finally got a chance to look through the app in more detail. I like your plans and map! I do agree with most of the above discussion about moving Saltpans town and Quiet Isle a bit more upstream, though I wouldn't go as far as #8 with the former. Other than that, I have some...

IronGentleGiant Jakethesnake8_8 I approve of both your minis (sorry for the delay)

I think Cornwall is a great inspiration for Massey's hook both in terms of terrain and regional style! In case it's helpful to anyone, here's a massive album of photos that I took while in Cornwall (unfortunately the order got completely scrambled):

Talked with Batel about his plans in-game and I'm happy to approve! Just a couple notes from our discussion: - I'd be fine with the open-air theater being made about 1.5x larger after being moved into the space of the current tavern, keeping the same overall design though. - Since it turns out...

Approved

Hey Tobi, I’ve had a chance to look over the app, and I think your plans and tests look pretty good! The only thing I’m unsure about is the hydrology. It seems like your streams are “backwards” in that they start as a single channel and then bifurcate. Natural bifurcation is pretty rare (except...

I wouldn't mind adding hoarfrost wood blocks at some point. For now I think the white wood is a decent substitute, and if we get hoarfroast wood in the future it'll probably be easy to do a batch replace (is there any other use of white wood planks in the snowy North?) A snow overlay block...

Approved