Search results

The moderator team has decided to reject this redo appeal, on the grounds that the project is too complete to warrant a redo under the Abandoned Build clause. However, the team would like to add that you are more than welcome to do a foster-style project, perhaps in cooperation with our foster...

Approved EDIT: You don't need pizza approval as he is busy - approved in his stead too.

Consider my temporary rejection of this application permanently undone. Thanks for taking the time and effort to go through the application processes for not one but two hamlets. Good luck with your application!

Hey endy, sorry to hit the breaks on this project as quickly as Im about to do. Due to not meeting the required criteria for project applications, I am going to have to temporarily reject this application. Nothing is wrong with the application itself, the tests are nice and I like a lot of the...

The mod team has voted in favour of the Dreadfort Redo appeal. The normal application process may now go ahead!

Hey Stoop thanks for the feedback (please note future feed-backers that, as Stoop has done, categorizing feedback is good - and titles great): Terrain: I agree that there can be more hilly incorporation of terrain around the town. Ill look at making the terrain more hill like for all areas...

I'll look into it later in the project. I likely will want to expand later anyway if I come across any particularly inspirational pics or ideas, likely opening the areas as subprojects.

Hey Stoop, thanks for the feedback: 1. This was to meet the description of the town's 'walls' (rather than just 'wall', singular). However I think that walls could be interpreted as a single wall, in which case I agree it may be too dense on that side of the river. I am unsure how to approach...

1. Hard to tell what the issue with positioning is (maybe more a subjective thing?). Love the town though and will take it into account when planning. It seems to be positioned on both sides of the river, if thats what you mean? I mainly chose to only position on one side since that was the...

Link here for my project application for the town of Stoney Sept. The project was approved for redo under clause 1(b) of the No-Redo Rule.

I am personally keen on corner towers for the lower base. I agree however that on the old model you were referring to they stuck out too much. I think the best compromise would be to incorporate them but only one or two out from the fort proper (might even use walls if they work out).

Its not so much that its not a priority and more that any and all future redos must go through the appeal process to occur (server builds included). I am happy to close this thread but mainly wanted to make sure that the issue wasn't confused as being one of priority but rather of redos in...

Hey jmc, I think you may have misunderstood. It is okay for you to apply for a redo, but only after you have successfully appealed for the ability to redo the project. As such, while Emot and Eld have allegedly said you should redo Ball, you will still need to submit an application of appeal...

I am unsure sorry Tham whether its still around. I remember it use to be but a lot of movement of the OT test area occurred outside of my knowledge (creation of otBI warp, etc). I'd love it if it could be found though, I'd really appreciate the ideas for interiors. :D

Hey so I've looked through the app and just need to go through it more thoroughly with actual feedback. Currently, besides the ideas suggested beforehand, your app Fin is the only one with a full test and accompanying ideas. I suspect it will strongly influence the final tower, but I will note...

Do not change the stairs. Beyond the fact they have indeed been used outside of slate roofs, it would be seriously jarring to the normal minecraft aesthetic. Conquest is a good example of not breaking the mc aesthetic with their wheels, etc. You will also have the issue that all our wood roofs...

Bump! Twenty days have passed since this first post, with no ideas, proposals, or feedback having yet been received here. I am aware of a few tests in progress, and encourage any builders to make haste in posting those proposals/ideas to this forum. It is admittedly disappointing to see a lack...

Absolutely love it! Don't mind either version, would prefer the one with the black fort on the bottom since it adds that extra contrast of detail, but love both all the same :D

Hey Cash, looks great. My one final request (but this is entirely personal preference, tho leading the Hightower I'd ask you consider it =P) is that the Hightower banner has the same shaped bottom as either the Lannister banner you first posted (three points) or the new Tully banner (rounded...