Search results

I absolutely love the birch planks! I do notice that the second-to-bottom plank stands out as being a lot darker on the horizontal planks - specifically spruce, jungle, oak, red, green and yellow - which creates an obvious stripe when used on a large area. The contrast doesn't seem as pronounced...

Hey Zanji, I'm sorry I cannot get in game to do an official post-approval - I have no access to a computer to do this from currently. Having said that, I trust Iwan's judgement and assessment of your project and am happy to sign off on it and allow you to move on. Congratulations, and best of...

Hey I'm so sorry I seem to have totally forgotten about this. I've been very busy irl, but it wasn't cool for me to leave you totally hanging on this either. I'm not sure if you're still interested in this, but if you are I'm happy to give you my approval. The tests and map look excellent.

Approved from me - looking forward to seeing you create an immersive landscape to complement the man-made features.

Approved, love the tests.

Post-approved

Hey, sorry I took so long to get to this! Went through it today, you've done a great job - I particularly enjoyed the Knott Peak, little challenges like that really make a build immersive. Post-approved by me.

Hey, still interested in this project? Sorry, it seems to have flown a little under the radar. I like the castle tests currently, and the house tests are mostly ok - one thing I don't like is the single block high stone foundation with a single layer of d&w on top. This makes it feel cramped...

Approved

I like the layout and the test - I will probably provide further feedback in game during the building process, but consider this application approved. Stick to the lighter grey palette for now. As this is a small immersion project, I am happy for you to proceed with just my approval. Best of luck!

Second hand stories of movement are better than no evidence pointing towards it being a stationary, stone-based structure. Your entire argument rests on the assumption that every piece of evidence that we have regarding Greywater Watch is totally incorrect. I can understand that it is a...

I don't think I agree with your argument re: Greywater Watch being in a fixed position. The evidence that we have from GRRM himself (via the books) points towards Greywater Watch being a moving castle, while your own counterargument is based on speculation and loose interpretations of canon...

Sorry I've been so inactive recently. I like what you've done. Only think I can really say is that the interiors are on the richer side of things (the fancy beds are too elaborate by comparison to the rest of the house), and the monochrome sandstone wall blocks on the facade are too light by...

Yeah sorry, haven't had access to a working computer for the last week and a bit. I'll get around to it when I'm able to.

Sorry, must have missed the reply. I think there are some positives but still areas for improvement. Things that I like: Reasonable house shapes (the one with the brown roof is a little bit short for having such a tall roof though) Solid grasp of the fundamentals (rafters, staircases etc)...

Hi Abraxas, Unfortunately I am going to have to reject your application as you have not followed the guidelines. Please feel free to reapply once you have done so. If you were not aware (I have noticed some people have not been aware of this recently), you do not need to apply to join the...

Hey Bovine, all that's coming up for me when I click the link is a photo of the balcony from the last build.

Hey Bovine, sorry for not getting back to you faster - I've been somewhat busy irl. Great work on the Duskendale house! Things I like: - Great overall shape and structure Things that need improvement: - The balcony seems a little unusually placed, and the amount of leaf blocks on it are...

I think you're making inferences where they aren't particularly helpful or necessary. We have next to no information on House Cupps, and the link you're making between House Hightower and the relative wealth of House Cupps is very, very tenuous. I don't think it's fair to use your opinion to...

You have my provisional approval - I really enjoy the tests, and I think you have made a great application. I must admit your plan to tackle the Dornish Marches is bold, but if you think you can commit to it then I would be happy to see it done too.