Search results

Hey Tony, Sorry for the wait; finally got a chance to take a look. Overall excellent work on this challenge, the houses you've made seem like they would fit right in at Duskendale! The only feedback I have this time is a few super minor things: - Avoid using stone arrow slits as windows in...

Hey Ever, I'm sorry to hear you're not content with the way the app's been going so far. Regarding the wait - I can only speak for myself here. Until I left my message, I simply hadn't had the chance to look at and think about the application to the extent that I usually try to do. I have a...

I'd also add that, while having high-elevation coastal mountains along the northern coast of the Vale may be geologically plausible (based on examples such as the PNW's Coast Mountains), it would make a pretty poor environment for large-scale agricultural settlement due to very strong katabatic...

Looks better; post-approved!

Just took a look - everything looks great, very nice work! I'm loving the pebble beaches. My only feedback is that I think the grass mix could be improved a bit. Rather than mixing the meadow fescue, heather, and other grasses randomly, I'd use heather predominantly in some areas (like around...

Hey Ever, Thanks for being patient while I had a chance to look at the app in more detail! Very nice app overall, the plans and tests look great. Here are some of my assorted thoughts: - The canon about the fertility of the Vale is moreso referring to the Vale of Arryn itself, i.e. the valley...

Just took another look at the tests; they look a lot better now, so I'm happy to approve! I'll have some more minor feedback on stuff but I'll give that once you actually get around to making it. However, I'm adamant that you don't use forest biome to try to get particular textures in small...

Just to clarify, they've already reached out to me and I told them they can go ahead and create a new probation thread as they're still a builder in-game.

Could you post your Video Settings so I can try to replicate this bug? Just screenshots of the base Video Settings settings, the Details settings, and the Quality settings should be enough. BTW, I just checked and I have my mipmap levels set to 2 without running into this, so that shouldn't be...

Hey Nathan, Nice to see you applying! Great work with the apphouse! Not really seeing any issues with it. Hope the exercise was helpful for learning our server's building style. For subsequent challenge builds, you'll be expected to build original houses of your own design, in the style of...

Hi Homie, Very nice work with the updated app, the project feels a lot better planned out now, and well-researched! Here's some feedback that I have after going through the app: - What's the motivation for using the forest biome for the Rainwood? If it's just to get the grassy dirt texture in...

Hey Tony, Very nice work on this house! You've done a good job with the gradient, which people generally have trouble with in plaster houses when starting off. Overall you captured all the important elements of the Tor style; I have picky feedback on some things though: - Try to cover up the...

Just wanted to bump this, as it still needs post-approval! Hopefully Veggie can get to it if he has time, as well as another mod since my previous approving mod stepped down.

Hey Ever, we discussed this appeal and decided that you're free to go ahead with a redo due to the abandoned and incomplete nature of the project. However, this is with the stipulation that, due to the high-quality nature of the existing project, you try your best to see to it that the original...

Hey Batel, We discussed the appeal and agreed that a redo makes sense here, given that the project is incomplete and of a dated style. Feel free to submit a project application (in a new thread).

Hey Axim0s, Sorry about the wait; was away travelling last week, so I missed your app. Feel free to ping me if I don't reply in several days from now on. Nice work with the apphouse! Not really seeing any issues with it. Hope the exercise was helpful for learning our server's building style...

Hey Tony, Sorry about the wait; was away travelling last week. Feel free to ping me if I don't reply in several days from now on. The apphouse looks good! It's a cute adaptation of the original house for a snowy environment. Just be mindful of the fact that you'd want to choose a different...

I approve of the update, though I have some feedback based on what's there so far: - I'm a bit worried about some of the style becoming too visually busy. We talked about this a bit in-game already, but the plaster palettes need to be cleaned up. Ordinary houses should only use at most 3...

Approved as well

Any mod can edit the OP; I can try to add the ones from the last few pages soon.