Recent content by thecoddfish

  1. thecoddfish

    Probation: witherack

    Why wouldn't you use daggers in a kitchen? They are indistinguishable from a regular knife, which would be even more commonplace in a kitchen than a cleaver.
  2. thecoddfish

    Completed Project application: Clan Knott By Johan

    I'm happy to sign off on this.
  3. thecoddfish

    SquizzesMC Builder Application

    Hey Squizzes, You've done an exceptional job with the Hag's Mire house. The angled house was a bold choice but you have executed it superbly, and you nailed the brief for the interiors. The only thing I can see you have forgotten is a ladder for the occupants to access the sleeping area. On...
  4. thecoddfish

    InvertedWinger Builder Application

    Hey Winger, You've done a really good job with the Tumbleton house. The exteriors are great, and your interiors have improved significantly (especially the top floor). I have also been impressed by how quickly you were able to get back to me with these challenges. On this basis, I am happy to...
  5. thecoddfish

    SquizzesMC Builder Application

    Hey Squizzes, Great work on the challenge house! Really impressed with your effort. Feedback: The exteriors are great, but do be aware that with vines you can also use the mossy cobblestone (within reason) and that you can place shutters over the window blocks too. This is a good way to break...
  6. thecoddfish

    InvertedWinger Builder Application

    Hi Winger, You're doing a great job so far. The Tor town style was an unconventional challenge, but I think you've done very well for what is a difficult to adjust to style. Feedback: The gradient isn't correct. The palette you chose would have gone from monochrome sandstone -> arbor...
  7. thecoddfish

    InvertedWinger Builder Application

    I caught up with Winger in game and we went over the challenge build in detail. To summarise: Avoid bubble yards. Chimney is too prominent, should be brought 1 block into the house and tapered with wall blocks. Think about what things could be transported up a ladder (chests in particular...
  8. thecoddfish

    SquizzesMC Builder Application

    Hi Squizzes, You've done a great job on this build, well done! I can't fault anything with regards to the exteriors. Some feedback: The floor mix of planks, dirt and brown cobble is a bit unusual looking - I would stick to either plain dirt/gravel, plain planks or a brown cobble mix alone...
  9. thecoddfish

    Clndering Builder Application

    Hi Clndering. You have still forgotten some key elements with regards to your application. You should make a small-scale, fully-furnished, low-fantasy medieval style house that would belong on the server, using the WesterosCraft custom launcher. Additionally, there is one more key detail that...
  10. thecoddfish

    InvertedWinger Builder Application

    Hey InvertedWinger, Big improvement with this house, well done! You've taken a big step towards the server's style with this one challenge build. Some feedback: The house feels a bit too short. This is partly the lower floor being only 2.5 blocks tall (I personally like this in some...
  11. thecoddfish

    Completed Project Application- House Langward- Sappertsc

    Happy to approve too, also subject to Emot's condition. Good luck!
  12. thecoddfish

    InvertedWinger Builder Application

    Hi InvertedWinger, Cheers for the application, I'm really glad you decided to come back to minecraft. What you've built has a lot of strong points, especially with regards to the structure and exterior design, but it wouldn't really fit into the server at present. Some brief feedback: The...
  13. thecoddfish

    SquizzesMC Builder Application

    Hi Squizzes, Thanks for the application. I'm impressed by the backstory you have provided for your build, because it demonstrates that you have clearly thought about the regional and societal context of the house, which I think is admirable. Some brief feedback: Thatch should be less messy...
  14. thecoddfish

    Clndering Builder Application

    Hi Clndering, You've forgotten an important part of the application process. I would advise closely re-reading the application guidelines and finding what you've missed. Otherwise it might be nice to include a bit more detail in your answers and spend some time exploring the server before you...
  15. thecoddfish

    In Progress Update Application - District 22

    It still is the case. I was just providing some feedback.