The Spring 2023 edition of The Rookery is now out! Take a look to see the latest builds, guides, progress and development updates on the upcoming 1.18.2 switch. You can read it here:
You are indeed missing OptiFine (or activating some of its features). You are already on it, so I won't go further into it. Overall nice job! I don't see any issues with your starter house. With this build we hope you catched some of the techniques and ways we have of building here. Now your...
Oh please don't be sorry! You didn't fail anything, you are learning the way we build it is expected you don't get everything right the first time. Having said that, wonderful build! I have barely anything to say about it. As some of the heads behing Ghost Hill's town I would be very pleased if...
Overall good job! I have little to say, most of it you'll see are minor points. I quite like the look of it, and I love that you added a small retaining wall made of wood at the yard. One small tip:if you want to upload more than 10 pics per challenge you can use imgur.com, an image hosting...
The tipped cliff sounds interesting! I find it to be a more unique take when compared to a classic natural bridge made by erosion. Idk if it can help but here in Spain there's a village built over a natural bridge, maybe part of the castle is directly at the top of it? Not sure if canon goes...
PS: Upload a couple more pictures of interiors and exteriors so I can judge them, and preferably take them at day or with a night vision potion on. Our forums have an uploading cap of 10 images per post, if you want you can use an image hosting website like imgur.com to upload more.
Hey GreyCoast! I saw you deleted several attempts before this one, don't worry it's okay if you missed something. I recommend you checking again the application rules, I think you've missed some stuff hahahaha (hint: look at other builder apps, you may find it). It looks like you used the shell...
Hey Aferys! Lovely to see not only a fellow Spaniard but also one that studied History as well! Aside from that, nice work with the app house! I see no major issues with it. With this build we hope you catched some of the techniques and ways we have of building here. Now your task will be to...
Hey BobWat! You were indeed missing OptiFine, but given that you have been informed already I won't go deeper into it. Other than that nice work with the app house! I see no major issues with it. With this build we hope you catched some of the techniques and ways we have of building here. Now...
I have visited your project. I as you know built you a house a week ago in Hastwyck, and I strolled around the lands too. As I said before, I missed the fact about the yellow balls being possible castle locations, being deceived by what I read in the app and the balls' different sizing, which...
Re-reading your first post about the matter it seems like you have the intention of tackling this expansion as a new immersion app, which I think is a good idea. If that's the case, and it is done just before the Lonely Hills are finished (to tie everything together), it should go smoothly. I...
I'd try my best to respond to this message. Labelling a forum post as a "public call out" or a "public show" seems like a problematic take to me. Giving feedback via the forums has been a standard procedure since their existance, as that's what they are meant to be used for. They are a place for...
It is indeed a weaker argument than a direct canon quote, but aesthetics, realism (somewhat) and regional cohesiveness/coherence are aspects we usually take into account when building a project (not saying you haven't done that, just saying that that's were my feedback comes from).
Aesthetics I...
I assume you have no intention in updating the wiped down projects (basically Long Lake) yourself. A possibility could be to paste the few buildings that make them up again on the new terrain, even if they end up open for being updated/redone. Having said that, if we were to take option 1, what...
It might not be necessary to say it, but just so you know there's no problem in abandoning. Sometimes we loose interest, feel unmotivated, overestimate the scope of a project or our capabilites, perhaps our commitment to it, or time is no longer as plentiful. Generally abandoned projects...
Hey Marge! I have a suggestion to make. I see that in your app, as well as in your current ingame plans, Hastwyck is gonna sit on a cliff overlooking the sea. While that's a valid location for a castle, I feel like in general, but in the area you are working at specifically, it's a bit of a...
We've talked before and I'm quite happy with the app and how Stonedance ended up looking, I'm really excited to see you going foward with the Massey's Hook. As long as you take into account Jake's feedback, which I find pretty appropiate, consider this app approved! Have fun!
Side note, but...
An update doesn't prevent you from changing the terrain (which is the main reason behind the redo appeal) or adding more villages. Herston is not that old or outdated to justify a full wipe out, but there's still room to play with it and ofc blend what's currently there with the newer style...
After talking a look and talking with Emot about the terra I've also decided to post approve this project. Congrats! Can't wait for what you will do next!
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.